Is it actually good, or does it just look good?
Judgy rates the thing you're looking at — a product, an article, a post — from 1 to 10. The median is 5. Nines are rare. Glossy photos and marketing copy don't move the number.
One honest number, a sharp one-liner, and the full reasoning when you ask.
5 is average
Most things are average. Judgy says so instead of calling everything a 4.8.
Evidence moves the score
Disclosed materials, real construction, track record. Not adjectives.
9s are earned
Best-in-class gets a 9. “Pretty good” gets the number pretty good deserves.